Are you struggling to choose the right machinery for construction and landscaping? As a small to medium-sized civil contractor, you must invest in the proper earthmoving equipment for your project.
We know that handling tasks such as roadwork, excavations, and site preparation is possibly one of the most tedious things to do, and selecting between the two options – an excavator and a skid steer can be challenging.
Each machine is known to provide ease and convenience but in this case, which one would you need? The answer totally varies based on your application, the conditions of the project site, the amount of space available, the necessity for quick work, and lastly the possibility for utilization.
So, without any further ado, let’s dig into which one will be the best for your job– an excavator or a skid steer.
What is an Excavator?
Basically, excavators are designed for digging purposes as well as various lifting and carrying tasks in different applications. These machines are perfect for large-scale excavations, trenching, demolitions, and moving heavy materials.
With their long arm and rotating cab, they can rotate 360 degrees which makes them incredibly efficient on confined job sites.
Characteristics of an Excavator
- Digging Depth: Excavators can dig deeper than other machines, making them ideal for foundation work and deep trenching.
- Lifting Capacity: They can lift and move heavier loads, which is important for handling large debris and materials.
- Stability: Because of their tracked design, excavators are more stable on uneven or soft terrain.
What is a Skid Steer?
Contrastingly, a skid steer is a compact, heavy-duty machine known for digging, pushing, and moving dirt. Being versatile in application, skid steers play a significant role in backhoeing, cement mixing, pavement milling, tilling, wood chipping, site cleaning and so many other jobs. Thanks to their fixed carriage, they differ from excavators.
Characteristics of Skid Steer
- Ease of Use: Since their steering is independent on both sides, skid steers can literally “switch at the top of a hat”. This allows for the so-called “sharp edge” turning when the wheels (or tracks) are moving forward on one side while moving backward on the other.
- Compact Size: Best for smaller job sites with limited space.
- Versatility: Quick attachment changes allow skid steers to tackle multiple tasks, minimizing the need for additional equipment.
Choosing the Right Equipment
While we have learned the features of each machine, let’s compare the two and find out which one checks the boxes for your needs.
If your project requires extensive digging, lifting heavy materials, or demolishing structures, an excavator is hands down the better option.
On the flip side, if you are looking for a machine that can maneuver in packed spaces, then a skid steer is the perfect choice.
Consider your project’s size, workspace, and duties to guarantee productivity and success.
In a Nutshell
The choice of the perfect machine for your job depends on the tasks and environments of your projects. For small to medium-sized contractors, check out PQRS (Proquip Rental & Sales) for well-maintained equipment for your project conditions.
Don’t forget to assess your site’s needs, space limitations, and task requirements before making an informed decision.
So get a quote now for the right tools and get the job done effortlessly and economically.